Lawyer Opinions Split on Man City Appeal Success
Lawyers Weigh In on City’s Chances
An expert in football finance has shared insights into the views of lawyers regarding Manchester City's appeal against a guilty verdict for breaching 114 Premier League rules. Following a decision by an independent commission in September, City was found to have engaged in ‘sham’ sponsorship deals, which allegedly inflated their earnings by approximately £900 million between 2009 and 2018.
City has contested the verdict, asserting their innocence and claiming to have ‘irrefutable evidence’ to support their case. This evidence reportedly includes documents indicating that sponsorship funds originated from the Abu Dhabi government, rather than directly from the club’s owners.
Potential Consequences of Failed Appeal
The Financial Times reported on Friday that the appeal is scheduled to commence in mid-December, with proceedings expected to extend over several days. Legal implications for the club if their appeal fails could be severe. Potential punishments may encompass fines, transfer bans, points deductions, removal from the Premier League, or even the stripping of titles. Additionally, the Independent Football Regulator might act to remove the owners depending on the outcomes.
The anticipated verdict from the independent commission on the appeal may be delivered in the new year, followed closely by a decision regarding any sanctions. However, there is concern about the timeline of these events, as some sources have suggested that any sanctions could be announced before the conclusion of the appeal process.
Timing and Future of the Appeal Process
Despite the club facing sanctions in the new year, the precise timing for when any punitive measures would take effect remains uncertain. Legal experts have indicated that these punishments could also be subject to appeal.
The Financial Times reported, "That means the uncertainty hanging over the Premier League — the most popular domestic competition in global football — could still stretch on beyond the current season ending in May, and possibly for years to come, legal experts have warned."
Sporting journalist Nick Harris, noted for his expertise in football finance, has revealed insights from multiple lawyers with whom he has consulted regarding City’s chances. He posted on X: ‘From multiple lawyers I’ve spoken to, perhaps 25% think City will win appeal or parts of appeal but fewer think City will win substantive points. ie: will still lose.
‘Context: on the morning of the 2016 US presidential election, Trump had 26-28% chance of winning (max). But he won.’
